LETTER: It’s the individual contests that count

Canada should adopt half and half German model of electing government

In his Oct. 30 letter, Timothy Jones of Fair Vote Langley asserts that on October 19 Canadians did not get “the government that we voted for.”

The Fair Vote people count all votes for any party and then point out that these percentages do not even roughly match the percentage of seats won. Therein lies their error. In our elections, voters don’t select a party nationally. We have 338 individual elections. In each of the 338 constituencies, the right party, the most popular party, won. The Fair Vote people mistakenly total all votes as if that is more important than who wins each of the 338 contests.

Consider this hockey analogy. Assume that Vancouver and Chicago are playing each other for the Stanley Cup. Assume, not unrealistically, that of the seven games Vancouver wins three, with scores of 7:2, 7:1 and 9:1 and that Chicago wins four with scores of 2:1; 3:2; 2:1 and 3:2. Using the Fair Vote interpretation, Vancouver, not Chicago, should be awarded the Stanley Cup. After all, Vancouver scored more than twice as many goals as Chicago. Democracy awards the cup to Chicago! What nonsense. Wins, not goals, count.

Canada may need a different electoral system. The Fair Vote people advocate “representation by population.” In its pure form that would mean that any party getting 1/338th of the total vote would elect an MP. Doubtless our number of political parties regional, ethnic, religious, economic would mushroom as they have in other countries. Italy has 35, Indonesia 23, and Israel 39. For Canada, such proliferation of parties would be disastrous.

Further, with pure “rep by pop,” there is no local MP. You would have to find one of the 338 to help you get your passport.

Canada should adopt the German model in which half the Bundestag members are local MPs and half “rep by pop” members with a five per cent national support threshold, or three elected members, required. That way, we still retain our own MPs and small parties which garner significant support can elect some members.

John H. Redekop

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Abbotsford playgrounds to re-open Monday

City urges public to bring hand-sanitizer and maintain physical distancing

Police watchdog investigating after man injured during Abbotsford standoff

Man seriously injured during arrest on May 21 at Abbotsford hotel room

New executive director for Fraser Valley Child Development Centre

Karen Dickenson Smith succeeds Karen McLean, who has retired after 22 years

Annual Walk for Alzheimer’s goes online on May 31

Event held every year in Abbotsford now raising funds through virtual event

UPDATE: Man from Mexico reported missing in Abbotsford has been located

Police report that Antonio Fernandez, 29, has been found safe and sound

Only four new COVID-19 cases, 228 active across B.C.

Health officials watching as activities ramp up

Facing changes together: Your community, your journalists

New platform allows readers to make a one-time or ongoing donation to support local journalism

Feds looking at ways to reunite families amid COVID-19 border restrictions with U.S.

Some families with members of dual-citizenship have become separated due to the pandemic

Condition in kids with possible COVID-19 link being studied in Canada

This month, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued an alert to doctors about MIS-C

‘I knew what he wanted’: Kootenay man spends hours in tree as black bear patrols below

Francis Levasseur is no stranger to the outdoors, but a recent run-in with a bear caused quite a scare

COVID cancelled their wedding plans, so they married on a BC mountaintop

Ceremony was live streamed to friends and family around the world

Trudeau acknowledges racial unrest in U.S.; ‘We also have work to do in Canada’

‘Anti-black racism, racism, is real; it’s in the United States, but it’s also in Canada,’ Trudeau says

State of Local Emergency declared for Boundary as communities brace for river flooding

Warm weather and heavy rain could cause sections of Kettle River system to swell beyond 2018 levels

Large cruise ships barred from Canadian waters until end of October: Garneau

Last year 140 cruise ships brought more than two million visitors to Canadian ports

Most Read