Workers seen throwing chickens at a Fraser Valley farm from an undercover video filmed by Mercy for Animals.

Chilliwack company charged with animal cruelty claims video evidence manipulated

Defence wants info on video equipment used by animal rights activists in chicken catching sting

Lawyers for two companies charged with animal cruelty involved in chicken catching claim the video evidence that led to the charges may have been doctored or otherwise manipulated and they want to see the raw footage.

Elite Farm Services Ltd., the company’s owner Dwayne Paul Dueck, and Ontario-based Sofina Foods each face 38 counts under the Health of Animal Regulations.

The charges came to light after animal rights group Mercy For Animals (MFA) surreptitiously captured video of “egregious” abuse of birds at Fraser Valley farms in 2017, video filmed using a body camera by an MFA employee who got himself hired as a chicken catcher.

Crown and lawyers for the accused were in Chilliwack provincial court on June 6 for possible arraignment, but defence continued to refuse to enter a plea and choose a mode of trial.

“The reason I am not ready to arraign is I cannot tell my client what is the best mode of trial for him and his company,” said Martin Finch, lawyer for Dueck and Elite Farm Services.

“The reason we cannot tell our clients whether to have trial by jury or trial in provincial court or even Supreme, is there is a complete lack of certainty that we have received unblemished… video materials which have not been the subject of meddling or manipulation.”

The subject came up at the last court appearance, but at that time defence for Sofina, Morgan Camley, seemed more concerned about possible “inducements.” Camley brought this up again on June 6.

Sofina management tell Camley the abuse seen in the videos is nothing they have every heard of in their operations, therefore they suspect the individuals involved may have been induced to act.

“That person is playing those other people?” Cohen asked.

“Exactly,” Camley replied.

• READ MORE: Companies charged with Chilliwack chicken abuse want to see all video evidence

But since the last court appearance on May 13, defence hired a forensic investigator to examine the video evidence received through disclosure. Through that examination, the investigator concluded some editing or manipulation has taken place.

Crown counsel Jessica Lawn has said there is no missing video, but admits some editing was done. Some faces are blurred and at times the audio is turned off.

But defence said their expert also found some date and time stamps don’t match the metadata, and there is at least one instance of the body camera shutting off while both hands of the operator are visible, something that doesn’t seem to make sense.

For that reason, defence says they need the make, model and software version used by the California-based Mercy For Animals in this undercover operation, something Crown has not yet received from the activists.

Crown insists that is a matter to consider as evidence at the trial or preliminary inquiry stage and that there was no reason not to arraign on June 6.

“I continue to work with Mercy for Animals to get this information,” Lawn said. “I cannot see how it can continue to be a bar to election. It’s the Crown’s position that there should be no bar to arraignment at this stage.”

Judge Gary Cohen, however, agreed that the make, model and software used by MFA is indeed an important element for the defence in electing trial by jury or by judge.

”If the videos are good, this becomes a fact-driven case,” Judge Cohen said. “If the videos are not good, then this could be a technical case.”

The video, defence argues, is the key piece of evidence against Dueck, Elite and Sofina, although Crown insists it could run the trial without it.

“Jordan is a huge concern for us,” Lawn said, referring to the Supreme Court of Canada decision ordering that court cases be conducted within specific time limits. “The Crown could run this case absent the video evidence…. [The MFA investigator] also took extensive notes.”

In the end, Judge Cohen expressed concern over the delay in providing the technical video information since it could be important to defence.

Cohen put the case over to July 9 to give Crown time to come back with the information on the video equipment or at least a timeline as to when they could get it.

• READ MORE: Chilliwack chicken catchers accused of ‘torturing’ birds in undercover videos


@PeeJayAitch
paul.henderson@theprogress.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Gurkirat Toor has been charged after allegedly pointing a gun at another driver on Oct. 23 in Abbotsford.
Man charged after gun pointed at another driver in Abbotsford

Gurkirat Toor, 21, previously charged with purple-fentanyl bust

The Abbotsford Teachers’ Union stated that local teachers worked without heat on Friday as secondary principals’ and vice-principals’ were at a work-related retreat in Whistler. (Google)
Abbotsford Teachers’ Union says teachers left in the cold on Friday

Abbotsford School District disagrees, saying all buildings were set to 21C on Pro-D Day

The Fraser Valley Health Care Foundation held its inaugural Grand Gala in November 2019 at Harrison Hot Springs Resort. This year’s event will be held online. (Submitted photo)
Fraser Valley Health Care Foundation holds virtual Grand Gala

Second annual event takes place online on Nov. 20, raising funds for local hospitals

Abbotsford author Katrina Wiggins has been shortlisted for the Page Turner Award eBook Award for her young adult novel, Blind the Eyes.
Abbotsford author shortlisted for literary award for young adult novel

Katrina Wiggins’ book Blind the Eyes is about climate crisis and monsters

Abbotsford’s Devon Toews has signed with the Colorado Avalanche for four years. (Avalanche Twitter photo)
Abbotsford’s Devon Toews signs with Colorado Avalanche

Local product inks four-year deal worth $4.1 million annually

Provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry arrives for briefing on the COVID-19 situation, B.C. legislature, Oct. 26, 2020 (B.C. government)
B.C. records 217 more COVID-19 cases, mask use urged

Infection spike continues, 21 senior facilities affected

People march during a climate strike in Montreal, Friday, Sept. 27, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
Judge rejects 15 youths’ climate change lawsuit against Canadian government

Justice Michael Manson has granted the government’s motion to strike the plaintiffs’ claim

A woman walks through check in at WestJet at Pearson International airport during the COVID-19 pandemic in Toronto on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Strong support for pre-flight COVID testing ahead of upcoming WestJet trial: YVR

Airport is partnering with UBC, which is helping choose the method of pre-flight testing

It’s been eight years since Gordon Spencer (pictured), and cousin, ‘Lil’ Bruce Mayo, were gunned down in a home in Langley, and Spencer’s widow is hoping someone who knows something will step up (file)
Eight years on and still no answers in Langley double murder

Wife of victim makes public appeal for people with information to come forward

Langley resident Shaun Nugent, who died in 2019 shortly after he saved a swimmer from drowning, has been awarded a posthumous medal for bravery by the Royal Canadian Humane Association (Courtesy Nugent family)
Langley man who died after saving swimmer receives posthumous medal for bravery

Shaun Nugent rescued woman from Hayward Lake near Mission in July of 2019

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

Washington State Department of Agriculture workers, wearing protective suits and working vacuumed a nest of Asian giant hornets from a tree Saturday, Oct. 24, 2020, in Blaine, Wash. Scientists in Washington state discovered the first nest earlier in the week of so-called murder hornets in the United States and worked to wipe it out Saturday morning to protect native honeybees. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
Nest of ‘murder hornets’ found near South Surrey

String of traps set up along border to capture Asian giant hornets

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau provides an update on the COVID pandemic during a press conference in Ottawa on Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Trudeau says pandemic ‘really sucks,’ and that Christmas gatherings are up in the air

The prime minister encouraged residents to continue to follow the advice of local health authorities

Most Read